Home
Blogs

Selling on Amazon vs Ebay 101: The Essential Guide

23rd Mar 2023
5 minutes

More than two decades back, if you wanted something from a store more than a mile away, the only option was to drive up there. If you wanted to purchase a pair of trousers, the only option was to go to the store and try them before purchasing them.

 

All of this changed with the evolution of shopping from brick-and-mortar stores to online spaces. More people today have started shifting to shopping online rather than visiting a brick-and-mortar store. A study shows that in 2022, there were more than 214.7 million online shoppers in the US spending over $4500 per person on average.

 

The average amount spent per shopper per visit in 2022 was $2.39. Shoppers love convenience. Two primary reasons consumers prefer shopping online are direct home delivery and a 24x7 shopping experience.

 

Gone are the days when the only choice to purchase something was to head out of the house. Most marketplaces have websites and shopping apps from which consumers can buy products.

 

Online shopping has made it convenient for shoppers to purchase anything from clothing to automobiles to electronics, skincare, and even grocery. Not just that, online shopping has enabled consumers to purchase directly from different online retailers (business to consumer) and also directly sell to other consumers (consumer to consumer) on sites like Etsy and eBay.

 

While the online market globally hit close to 4 trillion in 2020, the US market alone is expected to grow to 300 million shoppers in 2023.

 

For sellers, the biggest challenge is identifying which platform is the best for selling their products. There are two primary reasons you might be reading this article today.

 

  1. You are an online shop owner, probably already selling on various marketplaces, and aren't getting much results.
  2. Your business is entering the online space, and you want to ensure you choose the right marketplace before you set foot in for good. You are testing the waters.

 

Today we dive deep into understanding two eCommerce giants in the US - Amazon and eBay. Both marketplaces have been around for more than two decades selling products in a wide range of categories and catering to consumers worldwide.

 

Today we will understand everything about both these global marketplaces, what they offer, their pricing for sellers, the pros and cons of trading on these platforms, and lastly, which marketplace is the best for you.

 

Let's begin!

 

An Overview of Amazon

 

What is Amazon marketplace?

 

What started as an online bookstore named Cadabra in a tiny garage in Bellevue, Washington, in 1994, today sells products from over 25000 different categories, from books to electronics to clothing and more, under the Amazon brand.

 

Jeff Bezos's Amazon is today the world's largest marketplace, with more than 300 million active customer accounts, and caters to 180 countries globally.

 

Since its inception in 1994, the company went public within three years and today. In 2021, Amazon's net profit was $469.82 billion. And as of 2022, the brand's worth was $705.65 million.

 

In 2019, Amazon had approximately 1.1 million active sellers in the United States alone. Today, Amazon has tons of resources to help eCommerce sellers boost their revenue on the platform through workshops, events, and more.

 

Most sellers do not even have to set up a website to host their products. Amazon has over 300 million users and caters to 180 countries worldwide, and most sellers can ship their products to most of these countries.

 

If you already have an eCommerce website or a Shopify store, hosting your product on Amazon can help add another income stream to your online business. Also, hosting your product on Amazon automatically gives Amazon's regular customers a sense of trust in the products sold on the website.

 

If you are wondering if selling on Amazon is profitable, More than 65% of sellers on Amazon made profits within the first year of their operation. Amazon has something known as the Prime Day sale (usually two days), where consumers purchase various products at massive discounts. In 2020, Amazon's vendors made more than $3 billion in sales on Prime Day.

 

What's Amazon's demographic?

 

Amazon's convenient shipping and return policies have made it easier for both consumers and sellers. No wonder Amazon takes a major piece of the pie when it comes down to market share. Amazon owns almost 40% of the total market share, which is way above Walmart (6.3%) - the second largest marketplace in the USA.

 

Based on a research conducted in June 2022, Amazon Prime users as per their age group are as follows.

  • Almost 80% are 'bridge millennials' (33 - 42 years).
  • Followed by 77% being millennials (26 - 41 years)
  • Approximately 71% Gen X (42 - 57 years)
  • Followed by 57% Gen Z (18 - 25 years)

 

What's Amazon's demographic?

 

Most of Amazon's consumers make at least $100,000 annually and are 45 - 54 years married women. However, Amazon's target audience is still much more extensive than that, as it caters to a wide range of people from different countries.

 

What can I sell on Amazon?

 

The following is a list of some of the most popular products sold on Amazon:

  • Home Entertainment
  • Home office furniture
  • Cookware and cutlery
  • Fitness equipment and apparel
  • Laptops
  • Fashion apparel
  • Electronics
  • Gift cards
  • Video games
  • Books
  • Jewelry
  • Skincare and beauty products
  • Kitchenware
  • Sport equipment
  • Music instruments
  • Pet supplies

 

If you are wondering if you can sell anything under the sun on Amazon, you are wrong! Amazon prohibits sellers from selling a list of specific products on the platform. Vendors are allowed to sell only new products in most cases on Amazon. Also, except for wine, all alcoholic drinks are prohibited on Amazon.

 

But how is Amazon different from eBay? Let's find out!

 

An Overview of eBay

 

What is eBay?

 

Founded by Pierre Omidyar, what started as an auction website in 1995, is today America's fourth-largest online marketplace.

 

Did you know? eBay was initially called 'Auction Web.' Only in 1997, after Omidyar decided to turn his hobby into a full-time business, Auction Web became what is popularly known today as eBay. As of June 2022, eBay had about 135 million active buyers globally.

 

As of September 30, 2022, eBay's net income for twelve months was $28 million. Today eBay ships to 66 different countries globally.

 

While eBay generally started as a platform to sell used goods, now about 80% of goods sold on eBay are new. eBay has a total of 1.7 billion listings, of which nearly 28% of sellers are based in the USA.

 

eBay sellers, on average, earn $35,000 per year, while some top sellers make about $70,000. Most of the seller's earnings depend on how much they manage to sell on eBay and any additional expenses sellers may incur, like shipping costs.

 

Some of the products sold on eBay include:

  • Laptops, notebooks, smartphones, and other electronics
  • Home surveillance systems
  • Sports memorabilia
  • Collectibles
  • Antiques
  • Arts and crafts
  • Toys and video games
  • Sports equipment
  • Apparel and accessories
  • Health and beauty products
  • Jewelry and watches
  • Websites, domain names, and apps
  • Medical and lab equipment
  • Industrial equipment
  • Auto parts
  • Boats, ATVs, scooters, and motorcycles

 

However, just like Amazon, eBay too has a list of prohibited items sellers aren't allowed to sell on the platform. This list includes firearms, hazardous items, prescription drugs, lock-picking devices, stolen property, and more.

 

What's eBay's demographic?

 

eBay is popular among men mainly because of products sold on the platform, like electronic devices, automobile parts, woodworking accessories, and more. These items are some of the best-selling things among men.

 

eBay's audience consists of 62% men and 38% female. The age group least likely to purchase from eBay is 65+ years. At the same time, their largest audience is 18 to 24 years (Gen Z).

 

Now that we've got an overview of both Amazon and eBay, it is time to understand the different plans both platforms offer to sellers.

 

Merchant Plans: eBay v/s Amazon

 

Which is better eBay or Amazon?

 

Amazon and eBay both have various plans that sellers can choose from. Both platforms have plans suited for different seller needs. Let's understand the plans of each of these brands individually.

 

eBay's merchant plans

 

eBay primarily offers two different plans. eBay allows individuals to set up a personal account to sell their products. This plan doesn't require the seller to have a registered business and is excellent for people who want to sell one-off items or for those who want to understand how the platform works before committing to it.

 

What are different plans on eBay for sellers?

 

It's that easy! eBay's Individual Seller's Account doesn't require you to pay monthly fees like the Business Account plan. On the other hand, the Business Account plan is for businesses with extensive inventories. Once you set up your business account on eBay, you can further customize it according to your brand's branding board.

 

Steps to set up a Business Account on eBay

Step 1: Choose your subscription on the Store Subscription page.

Step 2: Subscribe to an eBay store you like and click Select and Review.

Step 3: Choose your subscription

Step 4: Submit your order and purchase the subscription.

Step 5: Name your store and create your product listing

Step 6: Start Selling!

 

eBay has different plans for Business Account users catering to the type of business you are running. Following are the four different plans eBay offers businesses.

 

  • Basic Plan - is more suited for new sellers who want to pay low fees.
  • Premium Plan - This plan offers lower fees, but more business tools
  • Anchor Plan - This plan is suited for businesses with a large inventory
  • Enterprise Plan - This plan is ideal for large enterprises.

eBay charges a monthly/ yearly subscription fee for the different plans, ranging from $21.95 to $2999.95.

 

Amazon's merchant plans

 

Amazon, just like eBay, has allowed sellers to set up an Individual Account and a Professional Account. Each plan is well suited for different user requirements. Let's discuss each of these below.

 

Amazon's Individual Account

 

This account is well-suited for new sellers or sellers who want to understand how Amazon works before committing to a professional account.

 

Individual account holders are eligible for fulfillment services and basic selling tools. However, they do not have the option to run paid advertisements on Amazon.

 

Amazon's Professional Account

 

Amazon has designed this account for businesses of different sizes. Business account holders are eligible for Fulfillment by Amazon services and have access to run paid advertisements.

 

Business account holders have access to more business tools than Individual Account owners, like creating bulk listings, having their products featured in the Featured Offer category, and selling restricted items like Fine Art, Jewelry, and more.

 

How to set up an Amazon seller account?

 

Voila! Now that you've understood how to set up shop on Amazon, moving forward, we will discuss the fees involved in selling on both platforms.

 

Remember! Whether you sell on Amazon or eBay, ensure you optimize your product listing with high-quality product images, clear product descriptions, and image and product titles optimized for SEO. Use tools like DoMyShoot to optimize your product photographs for higher conversion.

 

Where should you set up shop?

 

Should I set up my shop on Amazon or eBay?

 

eBay and Amazon both come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages. Following we discuss the pros and cons of setting up shop on each of these platforms.

 

Pros of selling on eBay

 

  • Great platform for selling second hand products
  • Over 135 million active monthly users
  • Lesser category restriction compared to Amazon
  • Easy to set up shop and create a listing

 

Cons of selling on eBay

 

  • Competitive market due to auction based business model
  • Certain niches have more competition

 

Pros of selling on Amazon

 

  • Larger market share
  • Access to Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) to take handle shipping for you
  • Consumer trust
  • Low marketing costs

 

Cons of selling on Amazon

 

  • Amazon owns your customers
  • Higher selling fees
  • Stricter guidelines and policies compared to eBay
  • Extra charges if you opt for FBA

 

Wrapping it Up!

 

There are various factors sellers need to consider when listing their product on either Amazon or eBay out of which, two factors are most important - the purpose of your business and reaching out to your target audience. Choosing any one (or both) platforms should help you minimize your cost and maximize your profits in the long run.

 

Each platform as discussed above provides sellers an opportunity to reach out to a large audience base with minimum effort. However, each of them also come with their own set of guidelines and pricing.

 

Finally, regardless of the platform you choose, ensure that your product listing is well optimized with a clear product description, titles optimized for SEO and finally, high-quality product images using applications like DoMyShoot.

 

DoMyShoot has 1000+ product image backgrounds to choose from. Furthermore, DoMyShoot helps you optimize your image for eBay and Amazon according to the platform's guidelines without your team having to worry about getting your images rejected.

 

Request DoMyShoot for a demo today!

 

How to do product photography by using DoMyShoot?

Frequently asked questions

Which platform is better suited for beginners, Amazon or eBay?
Both Amazon and eBay offer options for beginners, but the suitability depends on your business model. eBay's Individual Seller Account is great for those testing the waters or selling one-off items, as it doesn't require a monthly fee. Amazon's Individual Account is similarly beginner-friendly but doesn't allow for paid advertisements. Consider your business needs and goals when choosing between the two.
What are the main differences in fees between selling on Amazon and eBay?
Amazon and eBay have different fee structures. Amazon charges a monthly subscription fee for its Professional Account, but eBay offers a range of plans tailored to different seller needs, with fees varying based on the chosen plan. Additionally, both platforms charge selling fees, but the rates and structures differ. It's essential to understand these fees before deciding which platform to use.
Can I sell the same products on both Amazon and eBay simultaneously?
Yes, it's possible to sell the same products on both platforms simultaneously. However, you must adhere to the guidelines and policies of each platform and manage your inventory effectively to avoid overselling. Some sellers find success by leveraging the unique advantages of each platform to reach a broader audience and maximize sales.
Which platform offers better shipping and fulfillment options for sellers?
Amazon's Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) service is renowned for its convenience, as Amazon handles shipping, storage, and customer service. This service comes at an additional cost but can save time and streamline operations for sellers. eBay doesn't offer a similar fulfillment service directly, but sellers can choose their preferred shipping methods and manage fulfillment independently.
What are the key demographic differences between Amazon and eBay customers?
Amazon tends to attract a slightly older demographic with higher incomes, while eBay's audience is more diverse in terms of age and income levels. Understanding the demographics of each platform's users can help sellers tailor their product offerings and marketing strategies accordingly to maximize engagement and sales.
Join our newsletter
We’ll send you an informative newsletter once a week
We care about your data in our privacy policy
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
FOLLOW US